I can already tell that we'll have agree to disagree on this one. Still, I'll share my two cents. Maybe this is simply semantics, but @ClonesAnnoyMe hasn't really encouraged anyone to carry out any act, only to refrain from carrying out an act. Also, if we look at the spirit of the law instead of the letter of the law, I think the rule you quote first and foremost is a safeguard against people manipulating other people into committing suicide. If that would happen, it would obviously be a disaster for this community. Finally, if he wants to help someone and possibly save them from a premature death, it doesn't mean that he is against suicide as such or anyone's right to commit suicide. As a, possibly limping, analogy I could be for the legalization of all drugs and everyone's right to use them, but still be worried that some people won't be able to handle them.