If we lay eggs, porn would be a bit more interesting to watch…..
If a bunch of people told you that their periods became pain free after going on a diet where they eat nothing but shit, would you start recommending a shit diet to others?
Of course I would never think eating shit is a good idea.
Could be. The opposite could also be true.
Placebo and nocebo can not be ruled out in the case of one person, but if it was me, I would happily take placebo over excruciating pain.
That is kind of the point of an elimination diet, which the carnivore diet is.
I would agree, it's common sense.
You are funny =)
A placebo wouldn't actually fixed the issue. There would still be reports of pain and the underlying issue won't be solved. Most cases of painful cramping during periods are due to medical conditions, like endometriosis and PCOS. Certain conditions, like PCOS, are also connected to an increased risk of other health issues, such as endometrial cancer. Diets, like the one you are suggesting, could actually worsen her condition, especially if it turns out she has something like PCOS.
Should have stopped at 'I should keep quiet'. Holy cow, way to be dismissive. No idea why men ALWAYS weigh in on women's health to offer their perspective, solutions, mansplaining and dismissive 'you could have it worse'.
what are you talking about? not trying to solve anything at all. i said i did not understand and i was sorry. i guess you have bad periods as well.
Placebo agent, no, placebo (power of mind) effect, yes it might cause a permanent cure.
Given that PCOS correlates with insulin resistance, and not eating carbohydrates reverses that (carnivore is zero carb), this does not make sense.
If you demand rigorous scientific evidence in the form of randomized controlled trials, there is hardly any nutritional changes left that one can recommend, as most nutritional studies are epidemiological, meaning they send out a questionnaire once a year and ask what you had for breakfast the last few months. Not exactly reliable data by any stretch of the imagination.
Completely disagree here, digestible nutrition and shit are categorically different things, and the comparison makes zero sense.
Zero serious evidence or even reasoning to suggest a short term trial of 30 days would be harmful.
Not to paleoanthropologists, they have zero serious doubt, not past the 13000 year mark, before agriculture became a thing.
Again long term, sure, can be dangerous from malnutrition.
First off, the best foods for PCOS includes non-starchy vegetables and fruits, not meat, especially red-meat. A carnivore diet wouldn't be helpful to those who suffer from PCOS. I'm saying this as someone who has PCOS. There is a reason why it isn't uncommon to find people with the disorder who are vegans or vegetarians, not the other way around.
It's directed to the person dispensing bullshit food information in the thread
Do you know how unstable it looks to tear apart someone's post like this? The OP isn't looking for your nutritional advice. And you need to be removed from the board for spreading crap like Seyfriend's work, which has been debunked (https://www.skepticalraptor.com/ske...y-to-treat-it-despite-what-the-internet-says/). No idea what planet where you only get a survey once a year. So much of what you say sounds promising but ends up sounds unsubstantiated so I think it would be appropriate at this point to have you share your credentials - what medical training and peer reviewed work you've conducted.
Yup well look up impact vs. intention theory. In the meantime blocking works for me :)
