Discussion Another stupid afterlife thread, because I like them :)

[AliceTheGoon]

But you think it's not made out of matter right?

It would have to be or else we'd have disembodied consciousnesses floating around.

 

[Deleted member 847]

It would have to be or else we'd have disembodied consciousnesses floating around.

You said that existence is evidence of existence,
how does that prove that the physical cause exclusive to nolifenopain 1 universe 1 (the cause being the reason why that nolifenopain is NOT the same perspective/theater of mind as nolifenopain 2 universe 1, two nolifenopains with atomically identical brains)
will happen a second time after the seemingly permanent disruption (from our perspecrive) of the acrivity of that consciousness
(a bullet in his brain would seem to be the cause for that)?

You're not aguing that it is possible for the cause to reemerge in existence (Reality would be a better word, let's switch to that ok?),
you're arguing that IT WILL,
and you're basically telling me that reality existing is proof of that, which doesn't make any sense to me

Just because reality exists it doesn't mean the cause of Nlnp 1 u1 must happen again after his (my) death,
for the same reason that reality can exist and not have pink bananas the size of a galaxy in it, ever, even after eternity

edit

Things can be nonexistent
Not everything that can exist has to exist

 

[AliceTheGoon]

You said that existence is evidence of existence,

I said it proves its own certainty. To me.

 

[Deleted member 847]

I said it proves its own certainty. To me.

we're going nowhere

I don't see the picture behind your words

we were talking about the afterlife and you said it was a certainty

why?

because existence proves its own certainty?

?_?

you always give these 4-5 words replies,
I don't even think you're interested in actually debating me, or you wouldn't give these half assed low effort vague answers

 

[AliceTheGoon]

I don't even think you're interested in actually debating me, or you wouldn't give these half assed low effort vague answers

I'm not trying to debate you, I'm just telling you what I think about it. I thought since you like this subject that you'd be interested in another's perspective. There is no doubt in my mind that upon my death I will find myself emerging from a womb or pecking through an egg or whatever is the earliest self-awareness. None, zero. I'm not arguing that you should feel the same way about it.

 

[Deleted member 847]

I'm not trying to debate you, I'm just telling you what I think about it. I thought since you like this subject that you'd be interested in another's perspective. There is no doubt in my mind that upon my death I will find myself emerging from a womb or pecking through an egg or whatever is the earliest self-awareness. None, zero. I'm not arguing that you should feel the same way about it.

Sounds a little bit religious.