N

noname223

Archangel
Aug 18, 2020
5,001
I have one bipolar friend. She wants to become a therapist but probably never will become one due to her illness. She is always so fucking positive. When I told her I feel like I don't belong to this world. I am just not made for it. She told me she completely relates to that and this is why she came to the conclusion she has to change the world. My inner thought was "Well I probably have to kill myself then" but did not say that out loud to that time. She knew I had suicidal thoughts. But never how intense and serious they were. I considered to kill myself some days ago. And I wanted that some people know my reasoning about this decision. I am not sure whether I want to do this for me or for them. I want to be understood. I want that they have it easier to cope with it. And I hope they won't lable it as an irrational action done impulsively without really considering alternatives. After she said the thing about changing the world I almost lost interest in the contact. Such a reasoning sounds completely ridiculous and naive. But I like her still she is smart and she also suffers a lot. Well the talk had no good outcome as you might assumed by the title of this thread.

I try to sum it up. I told her how much I struggle about my extreme fears and anxiety. She wondered why therapy did not work for me. (I tried that 3 times). She wanted to know whether I really was engaged in the therapy with my full will. And yes I absolutely did that espcecially at the last one. I told her I am still ruminating excessively every single day and that my sorrows overwhelm me daily. I told her I know the roots of my problems. That in my first interactions with crushs I turn psychotic which ruined so many relationships in the past. And that I die innerly because of the shame and loneliness. That I am unable to work and that I am so so fucking desperate having to endure poverty. I know I will kill myself if I end up on welfare forever other therapists came to that conclusion too (which I did not openly say to her at this point.) Then I told her that I am just unable to go through the insane pain from another crash from mania/psychosis into depression with extreme psychosomatic pain again. I am chronically suicidal since a decade I just don't have the strength to endure that more often especially due to the fact how hopeless the whole circumstances of my life are.

She replied that my sorrows and fears were disproportionate and unreasonable. Then she wanted to have a debate what I actually consider to be a life worth living or not worth living. I told her I cannot understand people in similar bad conditons who don't develop suicidal thoughts. She said if everyone had such a mindset humans would not exist anymore. (I later told her I somewhat sympathize with antinatalism.)

I elaborated on the reasons why two therapists gave up on me. That I had the desire to pull off my own skin since I was 15. That I am extremely anxious that this insane psychosomatic pain returns. (which is very likely due to the fact my condition is cyclic). I told her I had the feeling one of my therapists did not genuinely care about me when she gave me up (She was an horrendous therapist. At the same time I emphasized that another therapist cared about me.) I said to her that my psychiatrist only stammered "That, that is impossible" when I wanted to talk with her about assisted suicide.

Her reply was the topic suicide just overburdens many people. Well they are fucking psychiatrists and psychologists they should be able to handle that. This is no excuse for me. She told me she does not want to talk about this topic on the internet which sounded like a pretty lame excuse. For me it felt like everyone says we have to talk about suicide, this topic must not be a taboo. But if there are people with persisting suicidal thoughts where therapy and medication did not work they all find lame excuses why this topic is too touchy for them. Only one narrative is allowed. On facebook it is forbidden to say openly I want to have assisted suicide. Toxic positivity is allowed everywhere. But if your desperation is part of your daily thoughts you have to swallow it down in order not to ruin everyone's mood. And if there are places on the internet where can speak openly about your desire to die they want to censor it and shut it down.

She told me she kind of feels offended when I said I cannot understand why people in horrible conditions don't want to commit suicide. It is irrational for me. She was offended by that. (due to her situation) And do you remember it the exact opposite was the opinion of one of my therapists in that clinic. He said wanting to commit suicide seems to be irrational for him, He also called people who ctb insane. In front of her I defended him still. It is true he genuinely cared about my case. But she also felt offended because I said that I think the other therapist who gave me up did not care about me at all. (which was simply the truth)

I have the feeling the people don't want an open discussion with people like me. They all pretend we had to talk openly about suicide but when voices like mine come up they all find lame excuses. I am suicidal since a decade, tried over 25 medication, had 3 psychotherapies, more than 5 clinic stays. "We all have to talk more openly about suicide." (not her quote but the society). Bitch my ass. You don't give a fuck about people like me. They throw antidepressants at you and raise their voice "How dare you to insist that you want to die." Psychiatrists in clinics laughed me out of the room when I wanted to talk with them about assisted suicide. At the same clinic at a later time point they told me I felt too good for being in a clinic and that my psychiatrist should not have sent me again to another clinic stay. Well if you did not treat me like I might be more willing to give another clinic stay a try. But honestly I just hate how the psychiatry treats suicidal people. I am too rational to avoid a clinic stay simply for such an anecdote but honestly my life quality is horrendous and I am more and more with my back against the wall.

I am desperate.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
  • Hugs
  • Love
Reactions: ger3172, MadisonMoon and ipmanwc0
Chili

Chili

Member
Sep 27, 2023
57
People who think like your friend are so conceited. Change the world? I don't know why she would say that. I'm sure hearing that would make her feel worse if she had been in a similar place as you. Imagine asking someone severely depressed if they engaged in therapy fully. As if it is your fault that therapy didn't work. Also there are some HORRIBLE therapists out there, and, yeah. You're right. It can overburden people to talk about suicide, absolutely. But they should be trained to do so, and know full well that they are working with someone who might die. We don't say the same thing about doctors. That's so frustrating.

I see this a lot with my classmates, too. Just feels like they have some sort of rose-colored glasses on that make them think they're going to snap and magically fix all your issues. The role of a therapist is typically to teach coping skills, and to help YOU sort through your problems. They're like a mediator, and sometimes that doesn't help for everyone, idk

Sorry, but I hear this often from friends and those around me and it frustrates me. I'm sorry you had this happen to you, but anyone else would also agree that she way overstepped her boundaries and doesn't really understand how a lot of these illnesses affect people I hope you find peace with whatever you choose, and I can hear how you'd be angry with what she said
 
N

noname223

Archangel
Aug 18, 2020
5,001
People who think like your friend are so conceited. Change the world? I don't know why she would say that. I'm sure hearing that would make her feel worse if she had been in a similar place as you. Imagine asking someone severely depressed if they engaged in therapy fully. As if it is your fault that therapy didn't work. Also there are some HORRIBLE therapists out there, and, yeah. You're right. It can overburden people to talk about suicide, absolutely. But they should be trained to do so, and know full well that they are working with someone who might die. We don't say the same thing about doctors. That's so frustrating.

I see this a lot with my classmates, too. Just feels like they have some sort of rose-colored glasses on that make them think they're going to snap and magically fix all your issues. The role of a therapist is typically to teach coping skills, and to help YOU sort through your problems. They're like a mediator, and sometimes that doesn't help for everyone, idk

Sorry, but I hear this often from friends and those around me and it frustrates me. I'm sorry you had this happen to you, but anyone else would also agree that she way overstepped her boundaries and doesn't really understand how a lot of these illnesses affect people I hope you find peace with whatever you choose, and I can hear how you'd be angry with what she said
I am not mad at her. She is kind and sort of overburdened. I am rather mad at the society and the psychiatry for not acknowledging that cases like mine exist and that they don't offer us an exit with dignity.
 
M

MadisonMoon

Member
Oct 1, 2023
16
I hear you, painfully so. There are so many campaigns here in the Netherlands stating that, depression in general and suicidal thoughts in particular need to be lifted out of the taboo sphere, that people should be able to talk about it. But the truth of the matter is, that if you really discuss it with a psychiatrist, you are met with impatience, even hostility and it is okay to give up on you - because you're being 'difficult' and don't want to be helped.

It is this giving of mixed signals which is just incredibly painful, because you turn even more insecure. It almost feels like being gaslit. Rather than child support, people should be given support when they want to opt out from this world that is already being drained from its resources due to over-population and hyper-consumption. Give people who want to opt out room to fulfill some modest dying wishes, and help them with a humane way to leave this life.

For sure don't go "Oh we need to lift it out of this taboo sphere!" and then all but punish people who come forward to talk about having suicidal thoughts/feelings/ideations.
 
Last edited:
  • Hugs
Reactions: noname223

Similar threads

N
Replies
6
Views
201
Offtopic
Mirrory Me
Mirrory Me
L
Replies
17
Views
474
Suicide Discussion
Rockman
Rockman
meowingnomore
Replies
1
Views
169
Suicide Discussion
Forever Sleep
F