Well , you kinda are ;)
I understand your intentions were good, you were harshly and aggressively criticized, and I'm sorry for that -- I'm not here to criticize but to explain. "Give life a chance" -- which came from a genuine, emphatic, compassionate place -- is
generally a hallow cliche without much meaning or help ; that members often hear on prolife helplines ; mentioned offhand without listening ; and often makes many even more depressed and stressed.
I really understand this did not come from a harmful place , but it can be easily perceived as condescending and dismissive (the way it was phrase). That's a problem. I generally try to be thoughtful with my words and not to trigger people, really thinking about every word I write, often rewriting posts before I click "post", even short ones.
I'm glad you are exploring people's situations here which is great . I'm just explaining why age or 'give a chance' (general) may be offensive for people who are sensitive to it.
People here are in
active trauma situation . (that is pain & ctb) ... It's better to pay attention to wording .
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Polarizing -- and Wording
I personally don't appreciate some of the phrasing occasionally used in posts on this site in general and/or the way subjects are sometimes represented: young-old , men-women , physical-mental , etc. I'm not speaking about the OP but in general . Presenting subjects in a
polarizing way is a problem . This binary / dichotomous thinking is not beneficial .
Especially as members have their own deep
resentment -- against women/men, old/young , etc ; and further more they have anger from the way they were treated by society which they may turn onto others as individuals or group.
This is a really unique place where abused women may talk with previously abusive men -- about ctb. (for example)
I assume if someone is here they are tired , exhausted , angry , hurt , and distressed (and that's the good case scenario-- there's also seriously abused or in danger) . I don't think such people can spare their time and energy. I can tell you what's better for you, but I don't feel a suicidal group needs agitation or provocation (intentionally or not) . While there is free speech and I'm not 'telling anyone off' , I hope we can discuss our angst and pain , our suicidal ideation or options of recovery -- rather than turn blame towards each other or 'groups of people' .
Btw I have done a similar thing when I wrote about
"well-off ignorant selfish Babyboomers" -- but I have detailed the caveats and who I'm referring to, and acknowledged it's just a portion of that demographic. I personally think that crude generalizations are not helpful nor constructive.
I can see these threads becoming toxic --- members just spew anger at each other. I understand the triggers and they are real , however we mostly have bigger problems than "offensive post"
I hope people will take all of that into consideration.
* I don't know if mods (@Hasssssuùuu ) should look into some profanities and personal attacks here . #toxic