What a phenomenal response Divine Trinity.
I entirely agree that things are often oversimplified. Education and its failure are very much at the heart of this. What is happening with social media is just a symptom of that run amok and moving towards ever greater extremes.
I can only really comment about the educational standards in my country but I suspect it is similar all over the world. What generally seems to happen, is you are not taught to critically assess information. You would think that would be a crucial first step.
My own ability to attempt to do so sure did not come from my school years. It came from my father who was an engineer by trade and had a love of science he infected me with. If I asked why is the sky blue? He would tell me how it technically it isn't blue and then go into detail about the scattering of light and how a human eye works. He taught me to put the information I receive on trial like it all wants to lie to you.
I was very fortunate to have that before the ensuing divorce occurred and even after it he stuck by me until he couldn't.
School though does not teach you to put information or the people providing that information on trial. Or even assume any of it is lying to you because it has an agenda to deceive. Instead, you are rewarded for rote memory and knowing enough to meet pre-established criteria of hoops. Hoops that often get lowered for the sake of league tables and bonuses that come with them. So at the most crucial era of your life where child development is busy at work trying to settle on how to best do things in the world. You are not being taught anything all that useful in how to validate the information in the first place. Worse than that you are being taught to accept it all at face value. You will quite literally get punished for questioning the question. Fascinatingly I got thrown out of class for asking too many questions as if I were being disruptive... lol
You also get taught something that is not on the curriculum. Usually in a negative way quite early. The tribal nature of the school environment and where you are in the pecking order. In that moment Us vs Them gets entrenched. Groups close ranks, cardboard cut out villains are produced. The complexity of an individual gets lost to the concept of the group as a whole.
The long term result of that, which feed right back into why social media is toxic because of its walled garden effect. Very little challenges it at any stage. So lies easily become truths through repetition. Things simply get parroted. Especially if they feed into the dominant narrative of whatever tribe you ascribe to most. A lot of debate now isn't debate at all just sound bites. If you go beyond the soundbite people will often get confused.
We have now ended up at critical juncture at what that means. This applies to all ideologies and tribes, not just fox news or elites. We all have our tribes and that is natural. Its just civil discourse between them seems to have become rarer. Even facts can be viewed as offensive these days.
If your ideology cannot accept rhinoceroses exist because that would damage your tribe or ideology. Then it does not matter if you fly out and get a rhino and drop it on the person. They will likely comment gravity is especially heavy today while dying to an irritated rhino.
Critical thinking and logical fallacies would bridge this gap if it were taught as standard and everything wasn't over simplified. Because you would simply incorporate the rhino into your world view. So later on, be better able to deal with problems that may well involve rhinos. You would be able to realise what systems are in place that exist founded on exploiting ignorance that are doing you harm that cannot now be sanitised away by repeating lies. You also wouldn't assume that an entire demographic is culpable for the actions of some. Then treat all of that demographic in a hostile manner.
I don't really have a solution. When people ask me what can be done, these days my response is a cynical defeatist one. "Enjoy your slavery and paint your shackles the myriad of colours available while pretending you have meaningful choice." ( People don't talk to me so much these days...)
Like you, I have accepted we are pretty much the proletariat from orwell's 1984. That the inner-party have rigged the game so fantastically well we are going into an ever deeper state of division. Even our language is reflecting these divisive terms more and more. Social media is quite literally being weaponised to feed this division. Meme culture is certainly helping.
Wasn't too long ago I read about unethical experiments done on the populace against their will via it.
https://slate.com/technology/2014/0...or-sadder-to-manipulate-peoples-emotions.html
Politics is also harnessing Social media, creating fake people with opinions that sing from the same hymn sheet. Businesses will also create fake people referencing their product as if its a casual conversation. It all becomes manipulative noise devoid of substance.
I despair as I sit back and watch my seven-year-old niece with a tablet in hand staring into a screen. I can't help but be aware of weaponised psychology shaping her. Nudging her. Prodding her to pester mummy to buy more sparkle packs because the energy of the shitty game she is playing ran out. ( So shitty in fact I bought them a switch. ) I am aware in future she will face predators pretending to be fellow children into My little pony. A danger that when I was growing up did not exist. I am aware that she is going to be staring perpetually at false images of beauty that only exist because photoshop does. I have seen what that does to some of my former clients in the form of anorexia and self worth. I fear that her standard of education at no point will prepare her for this psychological assault. That she will be disappointed in how the magical paper does not guarantee a good job but certainly guarantees debt. That she faces a world where sadism has become almost trendy. Where acting like a slut before you hit puberty seems to be a new normal.
But above all I fear all the Rhinos will soon enough stampede in a manner that can't be ignored by any tribe. Meaning all the people I love and care about will likely get crushed and suffer. Because we are too stupid, divided, and greedy to get over our tribal stances. As well as seemingly learn nothing in what is supposed to be the information age.
(Apologies for my long-winded rant at you Divine Trinity got a bit caught up in it. I feel like we may well be on the same page in our awareness. Your reference to cattle was pretty much my own sad view of it. I would like to talk to you more in private if you are willing some time? )