Manletmachine1

Manletmachine1

Member
Oct 7, 2024
35
They pushing me to suicide by telling me my new song is trash. Is it really that bad?
 
  • Like
Reactions: N7_Alliance_Marine
Innereye

Innereye

Know thy self
Jan 18, 2020
292
The most loaded question in the history of loaded questions. No such thing as Good and evil my friend.
 
  • Like
Reactions: foreverfalling
nattys5thtoenail

nattys5thtoenail

goofball
Oct 6, 2024
119
I'm not gonna lie dude, the song made me burst out laughing. You aren't a bad musician, so don't get discouraged, but your lyricism needs a lot of work. We don't want to hear songs about Tattoo sluts, it's giving HR complaint.
 
  • Yay!
  • Like
Reactions: willow115, We Are Angels and PixelPlant
Manletmachine1

Manletmachine1

Member
Oct 7, 2024
35
I'm not gonna lie dude, the song made me burst out laughing. You aren't a bad musician, so don't get discouraged, but your lyricism needs a lot of work. We don't want to hear songs about Tattoo sluts, it's giving HR complaint.
Why is laughing at lyrics a bad thing?
 
Chaosire

Chaosire

Literally insane, legally speaking
Sep 23, 2024
128
I don't think there are many people that are actually 'evil'. Everyone is just human and does both good and bad things.

Your music ain't really my kinda genre. But honestly, lyrics are pretty good and kinda funny. Keep up the good work ^^
 
  • Hugs
Reactions: Talvikki
F

Forever Sleep

Earned it we have...
May 4, 2022
9,228
The creative industries in general are very prone to personal preference. Have you enjoyed every song you've ever listened to? If someone asked you to give your honest opinion on a piece of music (repeatedly) and you didn't enjoy it- would you lie to make them feel better?

Some people simply won't sugar coat. If they are asked (repeatedly) to give their honest opinion- that's what they'll do! If you think it might upset you- don't ask for it. Some people will love your work, some will hate it. Some won't care much either way but will be polite and supportive, others won't.

I'm sure no one is deliberately trying to push you towards suicide. They may be irritated by seeing you try to promote your songs in multiple posts though- so- I expect that's coming through too.

On the one hand, I think you're brave for inviting people to give their opinions on your work. Maybe that's necessary if you want to get it 'out there' I guess. I imagine you are doing this on multiple platforms? It's not something I'd be brave enough to do- because I know plenty of people would say my work is shit!

Honestly, I'm not willing to participate in listening or giving my opinion because, I don't like to criticise artists. I know how hurtful it can feel.

Still, when people have said they've liked it, you've seemed to reject the compliment. Not sure whether that's because you are genuinely insecure or, you maybe want them to argue back with more reassurance that they do in fact think it's really good. Maybe mean to say it but, a friend and I used to call it: 'fishing for compliments'. We used to find ourselves doing it to each other! Probably because we were insecure rather than wanting to be adored. Maybe a bit of both though. Rightly or wrongly, that's not always a quality people like though.

I think some people just generally have a problem with someone trying to promote themselves on a suicide forum too. It's a place where a large amount of users are really in crisis and even possibly at the end of their lives. I imagine you are trying to make a commercial success of your work? It isn't simply a way of expressing yourself? Not just a person sharing some art to express how they feel. I imagine this might be part of your strategy to become successful? To aquire as many fans as possible? People may not like that tactic here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: deathwish
Dr Iron Arc

Dr Iron Arc

Into the Unknown
Feb 10, 2020
20,893
I'm here because I am evil and the world would be a better place with one less evil person in it. As for your music, personally I don't particularly care for any music that's not from a video game that I'm familiar with so there's really no point in trying to appeal to someone like me.
 
bleeding_heart_show

bleeding_heart_show

Member
Dec 23, 2023
36
Nobody is owed validation or positivity. If you care about what you are making you will do it even if nobody appreciates it but yourself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ForgottenAgain
SteamaHorns

SteamaHorns

Member
Aug 2, 2024
53
Actually think your voice is good. I don't even think your lyrics would be considered bad in a technical aspect when it comes to this sort of genre. Main issue is the fact that most people will find your topics and ideas to be unsavory rather than it being a poor work of art. Though, I personally think that your choice of words is too simplistic which takes away from the overall quality of the song. Overall, I liked the song and even listened to it multiple times, so yeah.
 
EvisceratedJester

EvisceratedJester

|| What Else Could I Be But a Jester ||
Oct 21, 2023
3,294
You people are seriously falling for this?
 
  • Yay!
  • Wow
Reactions: Dr Iron Arc and astr4
N7_Alliance_Marine

N7_Alliance_Marine

Member
Sep 29, 2024
85
Good song brocel. Did you do the guitar too or just the singing?
Everybody Hates Chris Boombox GIF - Everybody hates chris ...
 
OnlyOneSolution

OnlyOneSolution

Longing for death = not enjoying life.
Oct 26, 2024
84
They pushing me to suicide by telling me my new song is trash. Is it really that bad?
I wouldn't listen to over and again but it is catchy. I'll give you a 6/10.
 

Similar threads

Rudi
Replies
10
Views
187
Offtopic
Rudi
Rudi
Call_of-the_Void
Resource Just a song.
Replies
0
Views
46
Offtopic
Call_of-the_Void
Call_of-the_Void
gnarly
Replies
2
Views
135
Offtopic
derpyderpins
derpyderpins
DynahWAY
Replies
6
Views
126
Suicide Discussion
DynahWAY
DynahWAY