Help Which would be the quicker way to die? Hanging or suicide by Carbon monoxide poisoning?

[Misery99]

I want to have a quicker death where I can lose consciousness faster. Would hanging by a 8mm nylon rope kill me fast? Or will burning charcoal on a bbq charcoal grill do it better? I read that in order to work carbon monoxide poisoning suicide, you should have to be in a small enclosed place. I could not find a exact place like that. So what's your opinion about what would work?
By the way, I don't have a charcoal grill or a rope currently so I'll have to buy one of those just to ctb.

 

[Ta555]

I want to have a quicker death where I can lose consciousness faster. Would hanging by a 8mm nylon rope kill me fast? Or will burning charcoal on a bbq charcoal grill do it better? I read that in order to work carbon monoxide poisoning suicide, you should have to be in a small enclosed place. I could not find a exact place like that. So what's your opinion about what would work?
By the way, I don't have a charcoal grill or a rope currently so I'll have to buy one of those just to ctb.

I'm not sure how long charcoal takes to pass out but with hanging, if it's done well you're unconscious in under 20 seconds from what I've read.

 

[Made4TV]

Hanging most likely. But that's more painful. Heat from charcoal (depending on how you do it) can be a deterrent for people but otherwise it seems more peaceful although might take longer depending on the concentration in your enclosed space.

 

[Misery99]

I'm not sure how long charcoal takes to pass out but with hanging, if it's done well you're unconscious in under 20 seconds from what I've read.

If I can get unconscious within 20 seconds from hanging, then that would be great. Would a 8 mm nylon rope would work for hanging?

Hanging most likely. But that's more painful. Heat from charcoal (depending on how you do it) can be a deterrent for people but otherwise it seems more peaceful although might take longer depending on the concentration in your enclosed space.

That's what I worry. My attempt being failed if I use charcoal burning suicide method. Would you think a 8 mm nylon rope would work for hanging?

 

[angelus]

I want to have a quicker death where I can lose consciousness faster. Would hanging by a 8mm nylon rope kill me fast? Or will burning charcoal on a bbq charcoal grill do it better? I read that in order to work carbon monoxide poisoning suicide, you should have to be in a small enclosed place. I could not find a exact place like that. So what's your opinion about what would work?
By the way, I don't have a charcoal grill or a rope currently so I'll have to buy one of those just to ctb.

Pure CO is the best. I have tried this method by mixing formic and sulphuric acid, then passing the gas through sodium hydroxide solution and collecting it into a balloon. I took half a breath and I had a black out in 3 seconds.
Search for Gulps gas generator/exit international.
A tent or a car would be good places to do it.
You have to make sure you have more than enough acids. I would consider 5-10 liters.

 

[peepo]

Pure CO is the best. I have tried this method by mixing formic and sulphuric acid, then passing the gas through sodium hydroxide solution and collecting it into a balloon. I took half a breath and I had a black out in 3 seconds.
Search for Gulps gas generator/exit international.
A tent or a car would be good places to do it.
You have to make sure you have more than enough acids. I would consider 5-10 liters.

5-10L? Exit international used less than that. Not sure though

 

[Ta555]

If I can get unconscious within 20 seconds from hanging, then that would be great. Would a 8 mm nylon rope would work for hanging?

That's what I worry. My attempt being failed if I use charcoal burning suicide method. Would you think a 8 mm nylon rope would work for hanging?

The only way you'll know if your rope works is by tying it to your anchor point and testing it by hanging off it with your hands. 8mm might dig into your skin uncomfortably but depends how thick/strong your neck is

 

[angelus]

5-10L? Exit international used less than that. Not sure though

Philip Nitschke did the experiment with 50 ml formic acid and 100 ml sulfuric acid. He said these amounts will release 16 liters of gas in 30 minutes, which is above the lethal dose.
I tried the experiment with the exact same quantities, formic acid 85% purity and sulfuric 90%.
The reaction's time was around 5 minutes, and I was able to fill just two ballons from the hose.
The reaction continues long after, but the amouns of gas are like non existent.
So I assume what Exit international showed in the experiment does not guarantee lethal amounts of CO. The amounts of acid needs to be increased for more gas to be produced.

 

[peepo]

Philip Nitschke did the experiment with 50 ml formic acid and 100 ml sulfuric acid. He said these amounts will release 16 liters of gas in 30 minutes, which is above the lethal dose.
I tried the experiment with the exact same quantities, formic acid 85% purity and sulfuric 90%.
The reaction's time was around 5 minutes, and I was able to fill just two ballons from the hose.
The reaction continues long after, but the amouns of gas are like non existent.
So I assume what Exit international showed in the experiment does not guarantee lethal amounts of CO. The amounts of acid needs to be increased for more gas to be produced.

Is the ratio 1:2? or can you just dump both chemicals regardless the ratio?

 

[angelus]

Is the ratio 1:2? or can you just dump both chemicals regardless the ratio?

Yes, the ratio is 1:2. Sulfuric acid has to be in double quantity than formic acid.

 

[Misery99]

Pure CO is the best. I have tried this method by mixing formic and sulphuric acid, then passing the gas through sodium hydroxide solution and collecting it into a balloon. I took half a breath and I had a black out in 3 seconds.
Search for Gulps gas generator/exit international.
A tent or a car would be good places to do it.
You have to make sure you have more than enough acids. I would consider 5-10 liters.

Wish I was able to do that method but it's unachievable for me.

The only way you'll know if your rope works is by tying it to your anchor point and testing it by hanging off it with your hands. 8mm might dig into your skin uncomfortably but depends how thick/strong your neck is

I'm short but I have a thick body. So I guess it would be uncomfortable for me. Would a 12 mm rope will have the same effect?

 

[ManWithNoName]

I'm not sure how long charcoal takes to pass out but with hanging, if it's done well you're unconscious in under 20 seconds from what I've read.

Unconscious in 20 seconds sounds good, but how long until complete death? Plus which is better: partial hanging or full suspension?

Would you think a 8 mm nylon rope would work for hanging?

I don't know how reliable this info is, but found this off of a UK website. The weigh is indicated in kgs. I assume the term 'beak load" means how much weight it can hold. Scroll down the page a bit to get to the chart.

Nylon Rope | Buy Rope

High Quality Nylon Rope: Twisted 3-strand, 6mm - 36mm thick Nylon rope. Very strong with high stretch. MADE IN EUROPE. LOW PRICES. NEXT DAY DELIVERY

www.buyrope.co.uk