J

Jessica5

Specialist
May 22, 2019
347
An end of life directive specifies that you don't want life extending medical care if you'll have no quality of life.

Do doctors actually obey end of life directives if you attempt suicide?
 
O

oopswronglife

Elementalist
Jun 27, 2019
870
It's a topic of debate in the medical community and individual doctors will respond in different ways. Some insist it's not valid because of their own ethics, others say the patient's wishes are final. I don't know if there have been any definitive legal challenges in any country yet. Here is a related article: https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/812112

Like all of this about all you can do, if you have to CTB and cannot find a life, is to organize everything that is within your control, then hope for the best. Advanced directives tend to be ignored if there is any doubt as to their validity and if someone is unsure they are going to err on trying to save you, rather than having a debate over your body, so it's best to not even need them.
 
W

wendydong1

Experienced
Jul 31, 2019
295
not sure. But i am going to do a living will and will anyways. I don't have any assets, but i want my best friend to handle my cremation and the ashes.
It's a topic of debate in the medical community and individual doctors will respond in different ways. Some insist it's not valid because of their own ethics, others say the patient's wishes are final. I don't know if there have been any definitive legal challenges in any country yet. Here is a related article: https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/812112

Like all of this about all you can do, if you have to CTB and cannot find a life, is to organize everything that is within your control, then hope for the best. Advanced directives tend to be ignored if there is any doubt as to their validity and if someone is unsure they are going to err on trying to save you, rather than having a debate over your body, so it's best to not even need them.
I disagree. If you don't have a directive, they will try to revive you. if you have a directive, you at least got a shot
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Lookingforabus
Lookingforabus

Lookingforabus

Arcanist
Aug 6, 2019
421
An end of life directive specifies that you don't want life extending medical care if you'll have no quality of life.

Do doctors actually obey end of life directives if you attempt suicide?

It depends on a lot of things, especially your jurisdiction. If you're serious about these kinds of questions, you can do some research and/or get an estate attorney do do up your documents and ask him these kinds of questions. (I did, and no one looked at me funny for being a physically healthy 30-something getting a will and estate planning documents done up... that made it seem like a waste to come up with a cover story about stage 4 pancreatic cancer and do a bunch of research on that, but whatever.)

Where I live, some hospitals (mostly the ones run by religious organizations) won't honor a DNR (do not resuccitate) directive under any circumstance, and I'm told paramedics are the same way. Even if I have my DNR pinned to my chest, paramedics have to attempt to revive me, and the religous-based hospitals will ignore it. There are also legal limits to what conditions medical care can legally be withheld for - if I'm braindead (persistent vegetative state), they can legally take me off artificial life support, if I'm comatose, they can legally remove or withhold IV nutrition and feeding tubes, but, if I slice open an artery and say "let me bleed out", medical staff are legally prohibited from listening to me. The approximate standard around here is two doctors agreeing that the patient is in a permanent comatose or vegetative state before life-sustaining artificial care can be withheld.

And it gets worse. My "living will" is not legally binding, it merely informs the person who holds my medical power of attorney about my wishes. So, even though I have a DNR and a living will stating I do not wish to be kept alive by artificial means, the executor of my estate (who is a close relative) can, and probably would, keep me on life support forever if I eff up my attempt and end up a vegetable. So, I better get it right.

The legal situation varies wildly from country to country and even inside some countries (different states or provinces often have different rules), so you'll want to do your own research and consult a qualified lawyer in your jurisdiction if it matters to you, but as a general rule, anything resembling a right to die is rare and usually pretty weak where it exists at all. (Otherwise we wouldn't need this forum, would we?)
 
  • Aww..
Reactions: Lifeisatrap